Using New York Times Picks to Identify Constructive Comments
نویسندگان
چکیده
We examine the extent to which we are able to automatically identify constructive online comments. We build several classifiers using New York Times Picks as positive examples and non-constructive thread comments from the Yahoo News Annotated Comments Corpus as negative examples of constructive online comments. We evaluate these classifiers on a crowdannotated corpus containing 1,121 comments. Our best classifier achieves a top F1 score of 0.84.
منابع مشابه
Picking the NYT Picks: Editorial Criteria and Automation in the Curation of Online News Comments
Journalists have a propensity to select online comments for publication according to editorial conceptions of quality content. This work considers various criteria for identifying quality user contributions for publication, evaluates how these criteria manifest in New York Times “Picks” comments, and operationalizes three such criteria computationally. Results indicate that many of the criteria...
متن کاملChanging Names in Online News Comments at the New York Times
Online news comments are often confronted with issues of civility and inclusivity, which are sometimes pegged to the anonymity afforded to contributors in those spaces. In this work we study one form of anonymity in online comments that manifests as users changing their display name when they write a given comment. We undertake a predominantly quantitative analysis of how display names are chan...
متن کاملConstructive Language in News Comments
We discuss the characteristics of constructive news comments, and present methods to identify them. First, we define the notion of constructiveness. Second, we annotate a corpus for constructiveness. Third, we explore whether available argumentation corpora can be useful to identify constructiveness in news comments. Our model trained on argumentation corpora achieves a top accuracy of 72.59% (...
متن کاملDoes the New York Times Spread Ignorance and Apathy?
Technological advances over the past century have dramatically lowered the cost of transmitting information over large distances, allowing high quality national media such as the New York Times to enter local markets. However, consumers attracted to outside media may consume less local information and, as a result, disengage from local affairs. In the late 1990’s, the New York Times implemented...
متن کاملMeeting the Challenge of Diabetes in China
China’s estimated 114 million people with diabetes pose a massive challenge for China’s health policy-makers who have significantly extended health insurance coverage over the past decade. What China is doing now, what it has achieved, and what remains to be done should be of interest to health policy-makers, worldwide. We identify the challenges posed by China’s two pr...
متن کامل